📘 Class 12 Political Science – Chapter 3
🌟 Politics of Planned Development
🏛️ Political Contestation (राजनीतिक विवाद)
- In a democracy (लोकतंत्र), the final decision must always be political → taken by people’s representatives.
- After independence, everyone agreed: India’s development = economic growth + social & economic justice (न्याय).
- But there was disagreement on → what role government should play in ensuring both growth and justice.
💡 Ideas of Development (विकास के विचार)
- Any discussion on development leads to contradictions (विरोधाभास), conflicts (संघर्ष) & arguments (वाद-विवाद).
- Development meant becoming more modern → like industrialised Western countries.
- Modernisation = growth + material progress + scientific rationality (वैज्ञानिक तर्कशीलता).
📑 Planning (योजना बनाना)
- Consensus (सर्वसम्मति): development cannot be left only to private sector → Govt. must plan.
- Bombay Plan (1944): drafted by industrialists, proposed a planned economy.
- After independence → Planning Commission set up, with PM as chairperson.
🚀 The Early Initiatives (प्रारंभिक पहल)
- First Five-Year Plan (1951-56): focused on agriculture, dams, irrigation & raising national income (through savings).
- Second Five-Year Plan (1956): focused on rapid industrialisation & heavy industries → drafted by PC Mahalanobis.
- Planning excitement peaked during 1st & 2nd Plans, continued till Third Plan (1961).
⚙️ Key Controversies (मुख्य विवाद)
🌾 Agriculture vs. Industry
- Agriculture did not grow much after first two plans.
- J.C. Kumarappa (Gandhian economist) → proposed rural industrialisation.
- Others → stressed industrial growth as the only way out of poverty cycle.
🏭 Public vs. Private Sector
- India adopted Mixed Economy (मिश्रित अर्थव्यवस्था) → public + private sector together.
- Critics:
- Private sector not given enough freedom.
- Enlarged public sector created vested interests, blocking private growth.
✅ Exam Tip:
- First Plan → Agriculture
- Second Plan → Heavy Industries (Mahalanobis Model)
- Mixed Economy → balance of public & private
🌟 The First Five Year Plan – Major Outcomes (मुख्य परिणाम)
🔑 Early Initiatives (प्रारंभिक पहल)
- Planned development initially aimed at economic growth + welfare of citizens.
- But unequal development gave rise to politically powerful groups → difficult to move in desired direction.
- Three major outcomes emerged 👇
1️⃣ Economic Foundations (आर्थिक नींव)
- Foundations of India’s future economic growth laid during 1st & 2nd Plans.
- Construction of Mega Dams → Bhakhra-Nangal, Hirakud (irrigation + power generation).
- Establishment of heavy industries in public sector → steel plants, oil refineries, manufacturing units, defense production.
- Major improvements in transport & communication infrastructure.
2️⃣ Land Reforms (जमीन सुधार)
- Zamindari system abolished (औपनिवेशिक जमींदारी व्यवस्था का अंत).
- Consolidation of land (land pooling) → small scattered plots brought together for better farming efficiency.
3️⃣ Green & White Revolution (हरित और श्वेत क्रांति)
🌱 Green Revolution (1960s)
- Govt. introduced → High-Yield Variety (HYV) seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, irrigation at subsidised prices.
- Beneficiaries → rich peasants & big landholders.
- Prosperous regions → Punjab, Haryana, Western UP.
- Backward regions → left behind.
🥛 White Revolution (1970s)
- Operation Flood (1970): organised milk producers into cooperatives → nationwide milk grid.
- Aim → increase milk production.
- Known as White Revolution.
- Verghese Kurien → ‘Milkman of India’ 🥛🇮🇳
🔄 Later Developments (बाद के विकास)
- From 1967 onwards → many restrictions on private industry.
- 1969: 14 private banks nationalised 🏦.
- 1950–1980: Indian economy grew slowly at 3–3.5% per annum (sluggish growth).
- Inefficiency + corruption led to loss of public faith in economy.
- From 1980s onwards → role of state reduced in India’s economy.
✅ Exam Tip:
- Green Revolution → agriculture 🌾
- White Revolution → dairy 🥛
- 1st Plan → Agriculture & Dams 💧
- 2nd Plan → Heavy Industry ⚙️
🌟 Planning and Development in India
(FACTS THAT MATTER – Beautified Notes)
📌 Key Facts
- Iron Resource of Orissa
- Due to rising global demand for iron, Orissa became an important investment destination.
- Several MoUs (Memorandum of Understanding – समझौता ज्ञापन) were signed for capital investment & jobs.
- Conflict arose:
- Tribal population feared displacement (बेघर होना)
- Environmentalists feared pollution.
- Meaning of Development
- Development = Improvement in living standards + growth in industrial production.
- After independence, govt. focused on:
- Poverty reduction
- Social & economic redistribution (पुनर्वितरण)
- Agriculture development.
- Planning Concept
- Planning = Systematic regulation of activities to achieve national goals.
- Inspired by USSR model to provide:
- Education, medical care, tech skills.
- Bombay Plan (1944): Suggested state’s active role in industries & investments.
- Planning Commission (1950)
- Set up as an Extra-constitutional body (संविधान से बाहर की संस्था).
- PM was its Chairman.
- Aimed to:
- Reduce wastage of resources
- Increase per capita income.
- Pre-Independence Efforts
- 1930s: National Planning Committee formed.
- Purpose: Collect data, set goals, prepare for Five-Year Plans & annual budgets.
- First Five Year Plan (1951)
- Drafted by economist K.N. Roy.
- Focus:
- Investment in dams & irrigation
- Land reforms
- Raise national income.
- Different from 2nd plan → which stressed heavy industries.
- Mixed Economy
- India adopted mixed economy (मिश्रित अर्थव्यवस्था).
- Co-existence of public + private sector.
- Aim: Rapid development + social welfare.
- Second Five Year Plan (1956-61)
- Emphasis: Heavy industrialisation (even in rural areas).
- Criticism:
- Benefitted urban/industrial sector more than rural areas.
- Failure blamed on political non-implementation rather than policy.
- Land Reforms during Planning Period
- Aim: Abolish Zamindari system, consolidate small lands.
- Result: Limited success ❌
- Political influence
- Laws remained only on paper.
- Drought & Food Crisis (1965–67)
- Severe droughts → Bihar faced famine-like situation.
- Food prices rose sharply.
- Govt.’s zoning policy restricted food trade across states → worsened crisis.
- Green Revolution (1960s) 🌾
- Govt. provided: HYV seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, irrigation at subsidy.
- Positive: Benefitted middle peasants, made them politically powerful.
- Negative:
- Increased gap between rich landlords & poor farmers.
- Growth was moderate & region-specific.
- White Revolution (1970s) 🥛
- Started in Gujarat by Verghese Kurien (Milkman of India).
- Launched Amul Cooperative Model.
- Benefits:
- Increased milk production
- Rural development & poverty reduction.
- Kerala Model 🌴
- Based on Decentralised Planning (विकेन्द्रीकृत योजना).
- Focus areas:
- Education
- Health
- Land reforms
- Food distribution
- Poverty alleviation.
- People’s participation from panchayat → block → district level.
📝 Words That Matter (महत्वपूर्ण शब्दावली)
✨ Planning (योजना निर्माण):
🔹 A systematic regulation to optimum use of resources and to reduce wastage of time.
👉 संसाधनों का सर्वोत्तम उपयोग (optimum use of resources) और समय की बर्बादी कम करने की प्रक्रिया।
💰 Capitalist Economy (पूँजीवादी अर्थव्यवस्था):
🔹 The economy in which private sectors are prioritised in place of social welfare.
👉 इसमें निजी क्षेत्र (private sector) को सामाजिक कल्याण (social welfare) से अधिक महत्व दिया जाता है।
⚖️ Socialist Economy (समाजवादी अर्थव्यवस्था):
🔹 It aims at the public sector and planning with the aim to establish egalitarian society.
👉 इसका उद्देश्य सार्वजनिक क्षेत्र (public sector) को बढ़ावा देना और समानता पर आधारित समाज (egalitarian society) स्थापित करना है।
🏭 Bombay Plan (बॉम्बे योजना):
🔹 A joint proposal of big industrialists for setting up a planned economy in 1944.
👉 1944 में बड़े उद्योगपतियों (industrialists) द्वारा नियोजित अर्थव्यवस्था (planned economy) बनाने का प्रस्ताव।
📊 Planning Commission (योजना आयोग):
🔹 An extra-constitutional body set up in March 1950 with the Prime Minister as Chairman.
👉 यह संवैधानिक संस्था नहीं (extra-constitutional body) है, जिसे 1950 में स्थापित किया गया और प्रधानमंत्री इसके अध्यक्ष होते थे।
💵 Plan Budget (योजना बजट):
🔹 The amount spent on a five-year basis as per the priorities fixed by the plan.
👉 पाँच वर्षीय योजना (five-year plan) की प्राथमिकताओं के अनुसार खर्च किया जाने वाला बजट।
🔄 Mixed Economy (मिश्रित अर्थव्यवस्था):
🔹 An economy in which private and public sectors both co-exist.
👉 इसमें निजी (private) और सार्वजनिक (public) क्षेत्र दोनों साथ-साथ चलते हैं।